"I can't remember if I ___" ("American Pie" lyric) — Crossword Clue
Stuck on the 5–letter crossword clue “"I can't remember if I ___" ("American Pie" lyric)”? This page covers its appearance in NYT Crossword on 3rd Nov 2009. You can reveal the answer at your pace — one letter at a time or the whole word in one go. We also provide helpful extras where available: an AI-generated hint, a dictionary definition, other clues that share the same answer, and a jumbled-letters view for quick anagramming.
Answer
Hints
Want a nudge without spoilers? Try revealing a hint or two, it might be just enough to get you unstuck.

Frequently asked questions about the crossword clue “"I can't remember if I ___" ("American Pie" lyric)”
The answer to “"I can't remember if I ___" ("American Pie" lyric)” is CRIED (5 letters).
We last saw “"I can't remember if I ___" ("American Pie" lyric)” in NYT Crossword on 3rd Nov 2009.
The 5-letter answer for “"I can't remember if I ___" ("American Pie" lyric)” is CRIED.
If you’re still stuck on “"I can't remember if I ___" ("American Pie" lyric)”, try checking other answer lengths or using crossing letters to narrow the solution.
Daily Game Solvers, Hints and Answers
We help you solve your favourite daily game